PSA vs BGS: Grading Dunsparce for Market Value Trends

Dunsparce from the Sandstorm set (ex2-60) card art by Mitsuhiro Arita

Image courtesy of TCGdex.net

PSA vs BGS: Grading Dunsparce for Market Value Trends

Grading Pokémon cards isn’t just about collecting pride; it’s a strategic move for investors and hobbyists who track value over time. When a card like Dunsparce from the Sandstorm set comes into focus, the question isn’t merely “is it worth grading?” but “which grading company will maximize what I paid and what I’ll get back on resale?” Enter PSA and BGS, two juggernauts in the hobby with different scoring philosophies, timelines, and market premiums. For a common basic Colorless card such as Dunsparce (ex2-60), the grading decision can still meaningfully shift market perception and, by extension, value in both raw and graded forms. ⚡

Let’s anchor this discussion in the card’s identity. Dunsparce is a Basic Colorless Pokémon with 50 HP—a modest profile by today’s standards, but a beloved piece for many collectors, especially fans of Mitsuhiro Arita’s unmistakable art. The art, surfaced on the holo and reverse-holo variants, captures the era’s charm and the tactile thrill of pulling a glossy surface in a sealed pack. The set, Sandstorm (ex2), sits in the EX Series era, where print quality and card stock created distinct challenges for grading. Each card’s typology—basic, rare vs common, holo vs non-holo, and surface finish—feeds into how grading agencies assess condition and assign a grade. 🃏🎴

What grading measures and why it matters for Dunsparce

PSA: A single score from 1 to 10, with PSA 10 being Gem Mint. PSA focuses on a holistic assessment, but it’s known for a broad standard that many collectors trust for broad market liquidity. For older prints like Sandstorm, a PSA 10 can unlock a premium simply because buyers trust the grade and recognize it across marketplaces.
BGS: A 1–10 scale, but with four subgrades—Centering, Edges, Corners, and Surface—each contributing to a composite and a final grade. BGS also uses the “Gem Mint 9.5” tier and a punchy black label that signals subgrades. The granular feedback (e.g., 9.5 for surface but 10 for corners) helps collectors decide whether a card really justifies the premium or if it’s better to pass.

For Dunsparce ex2-60, the journey from raw to graded is shaped by a few realities: the card’s rarity (Common), its HP and stage, and the surface finish (holo, reverse holo, or normal). Each factor interacts with grading criteria. The holo variant—favored by many collectors for its shine—often shows surface and centering flaws more readily, which can influence whether a PSA 10 or BGS 9.5 is achievable and, critically, how much value a grade adds. The card’s illustrator, Mitsuhiro Arita, adds a layer of desirability for fans who associate his distinctive style with some of the most memorable early-2000s Pokémon moments. 🔥💎

Market value dynamics: raw vs graded for Dunsparce ex2-60

Current pricing data paints a clear picture of where raw copies sit and how grading can tilt the scales. On Cardmarket, a non-holo basic Dunsparce typically trades with low prices around the EUR 0.50–0.90 range, with mid-range listings near EUR 1.50 and occasional high-water marks approaching EUR 4–5 for exceptionally clean or promising copies. On TCGPlayer, normal (non-holo) copies show a low around USD 0.90, a mid around USD 1.51, and a high near USD 4.98, reflecting the card’s broad availability and modest demand. For holo and reverse-holo variants, the market price vaults a bit higher—roughly USD 5.00 or more on active listings, with reverse-holo generally pulling a premium over the standard print. These figures illustrate the baseline: raw Dunsparce ex2-60 is accessible, but the holo versions are where collectors and investors are more likely to place significant premium. 🔮🎨

So what does grading do to those numbers? In general, PSA 10 or BGS 9.5 can unlock a notable premium over raw copies—especially for holo variants from older sets where print quality can waver and condition becomes a deciding factor for value. A well-graded holo ex2-60 may command a multiple above raw equivalents, driven by buyer confidence in the grade and the card’s visual appeal. The premium is not uniform, and it fluctuates with market sentiment, the prevalence of the grade in completed sales, and the overall health of the vintage market. For Dunsparce, the interplay between the card’s common rarity and the nostalgia of Sandstorm means grading is most effective when you own a copy in good surface and centering condition—areas where early print flaws can be less forgiving. ⚡💎

Grading strategy: practical takeaways for Dunsparce owners

: Sandstorm prints often show centering drift and surface imperfections. If you’re aiming for a PSA 10 or BGS 9.5, you’ll want a copy with near-perfect centering and a pristine holo surface, free of scratches and edge chipping.
: A holo or reverse-holo tends to carry a higher ceiling due to visual appeal and demand. A rare “gem mint” holo Dunsparce ex2-60 can push a stronger premium than its non-holo counterpart.
: Grading is a financial decision. The fees, submission turnaround, and potential value gain should be weighed against the card’s raw market price. For a common card from a 2000-era set, the upside should be measured against the cost of grading and potential storage concerns.
: Submitting a card with crisp corners and a clean surface helps maximize the subgrades on BGS and supports a high PSA overall grade. Collectors value transparency in condition reports as well as high-fidelity photos for online auctions or listings.

Bottom line: choosing PSA or BGS for Dunsparce

PSA’s broad liquidity and consistent market recognition make it a safe bet when you want easy resale and wide buyer access. BGS, with its subgrades and the prestige of a “Gem Mint” designation, can yield a sharper, more granular appraisal of condition, which some buyers prize highly—particularly for holo variants where surface and corners are under close scrutiny. For Dunsparce ex2-60, the decision often comes down to your goals: quick, broad-market liquidity with PSA, or a granular, premium-driven display with BGS. Either way, the card’s enduring charm—its simple but charming move set and the nostalgic artwork by Mitsuhiro Arita—ensures it remains a fan favorite long after today’s play formats have evolved. 🎴🎮

Neon Gaming Mouse Pad Non-slip 9.5x8in Anti-Fray