PSA vs BGS Grading for Diggersby: Which Holds Value?

In TCG ·

Diggersby card art (Fusion Strike, swsh8-215) illustrated by MAHOU

Image courtesy of TCGdex.net

Diggersby’s Grading Showdown: PSA vs BGS and What It Means for Your Fusion Strike Collection

Modern Pokémon TCG collecting often turns on one crisp decision: which grading service to trust when you’re turning a coveted card into a showcase piece. For Diggersby, the Stage 1 Colorless battler from Fusion Strike, this question hits close to home. Diggersby, with 140 HP, an earnest move set—Hammer In for 80 and Take Down for 150 (with 30 damage to self)—and an illustrated tie to MAHOU, sits at a fascinating crossroads where market value and grading standards collide. The card’s Uncommon rarity and its non-holo presentation add texture to the decision-making process that every grader and collector wrestles with ⚡🔥.

Understanding PSA and BGS: what each grade means for your card

PSA and BGS are the two most recognized names in Pokémon TCG grading, but they operate with slightly different philosophies. PSA uses a 1–10 scale to signal overall centering, corners, edges, and surface, with a PSA 10 representing Gem Mint quality that most buyers trust for resale. Beckett Grading Services (BGS), on the other hand, emphasizes subgrades in four categories—Centering, Corners, Edges, and Surface—giving a composite score alongside a yellow-bordered Creative Grading label when it’s a stand-out specimen. In practice, many collectors view PSA as the more liquid, widely accepted benchmark for modern TCG cards, while BGS can reward well-centered or pristine cards with an explicit breakdown of where a card shines or stumbles.

For a card like Diggersby from Fusion Strike, these differences matter in two ways: first, the typical price delta between graded and raw copies; second, how subgrades (in the case of BGS) influence buyer confidence for an uncommon non-holo. Since Swsh8-215 is an Uncommon with no holo foil and only standard / reverse variants, the premiums for pristine grading tend to be more modest than you’d see on ultra-rare chase cards. The decision often comes down to how you want to present your collection and how much value you’re hoping to unlock in a sale or trade later on 🔎🎴.

Diggersby in the market: what the numbers say

Price data for Diggersby swsh8-215 paints a candid picture of modern, non-holo value. Cardmarket’s latest readings show the card’s normal (non-foil) variant sits around a few pennies in typical conditions, with an average price near $0.07 and a low around $0.01, while the high price in outlier cases can creep toward $4.99. For the reverse-holo variant, the baseline is a touch higher—midpoints around $0.19 with a disclosed high near $4.99—reflecting the premium collectors place on foil treatment, even for an Uncommon card. These numbers underscore a practical truth: graded copies of a non-holo Diggersby tend to fetch modest premiums that may barely cover grading costs for a large, routine shipment.

TCGPlayer’s current snapshot aligns with that sentiment. In the normal (non-holo) lane, market price hovers around $0.07, with the low end dipping to $0.01 and a high watermark around $4.99 in some listings. The reverse-holo path moves that market toward the $0.19 area on average, still far from the kinds of premiums seen on rare or highly sought-after cards. What that means for PSA vs BGS: the added cost and time of grading must be weighed against a relatively small potential uplift—most buyers of a Grade 10 non-holo Diggersby are not chasing a massive windfall, but rather a convenient, authenticated piece for a completed Fusion Strike collection 🔍💎.

Thematically, Diggersby’s value proposition is strengthened by its interesting flavor text and lore—“The fur on its belly retains heat exceptionally well. People used to make heavy winter clothing from fur shed by this Pokémon.” This backstory adds collectibility beyond raw numbers, even as the card remains a practical centerpiece for deck-building and display. The illustrator MAHOU lends a distinctive aesthetic that some collectors specifically seek, and the card’s Regulation Mark E signals modern playability in expanded formats. All of this factors into who’s willing to pay a premium for a PSA 10 or a BGS 9.5 copy, even if the figures won’t break the bank like a holo-foil chase card.

Practical guidance for graders and collectors

  • Assess the cost-to-benefit: If you’re weighing sending Diggersby to PSA or BGS, consider typical grading fees, shipping, and the current raw price around $0.07 (normal) or $0.19 (reverse). The upside must outpace the total expenditure to be worth it, especially for a non-holo Uncommon.
  • Choose the right target grade: For PSA, a pristine copy that reaches 9 or 10 often sells well enough, but for BGS, a strong overall grade paired with solid subgrades (e.g., Centering and Surface in top tiers) can appeal to niche collectors who value the specificity. Don’t chase an artificially perfect slab if it doesn’t align with the card’s physical realities.
  • Mind the variant value: The reverse-holo version will typically command a higher price than the normal version—so if you’re grading for resale, that differential matters. A high-grade reverse holo might fetch a nicer premium despite the card’s Uncommon status.
  • Guard expectations on modern sets: Modern Pokémon cards, especially non-holo uncommons, often sit in a market where graded premiums exist but are tempered by supply and buyer preference. If you’re after a slam-dunk sale, broader interest in a holo or a chase card may yield a better return than a single non-holo graded copy.
  • Illustrator and set details matter: With the Fusion Strike set and MAHOU’s artistry, the card holds aesthetic appeal beyond its gameplay value. Some collectors prize the art, which can influence the decision to grade, even for lower- rarity cards.

In the end, the PSA vs BGS choice for Diggersby swsh8-215 comes down to your goals. If liquidity and broad market recognition drive your strategy, PSA 10 remains the most trusted path for resale. If you relish granular feedback through subgrades and want to showcase specific strengths in your copy, BGS could be the route that aligns with your collector ethos. Either way, this Fusion Strike Pokémon still tells a compact story in a sprawling collection, reminding us that value isn’t just about price tags—it’s about the narrative, the condition, and the care we pour into our cards ⚡🎨.

For fans eyeing the broader ecosystem of card collecting, the conversation around grading reflects a larger truth: care, curation, and context often trump sheer numbers. Whether you’re building a focused Diggersby run or threading this card into a larger Fusion Strike display, the journey is as rewarding as the destination.

Neon Phone Case with Card Holder – Glossy Matte Polycarbonate + MagSafe

More from our network